Sunday, August 23, 2020

ideologies: religions of modernism

For a period of about 27 years, I did not think; I acted.

And at that, I acted only towards an assured self-destruction.

If there was a Truth, it did not dawn gloriously upon me like a 'Born Again' Christian will attest. It was more like a consistent and steady blow to the face, knocking me out every time I got back up to make another equally dumb mistake. What knocked me down was a mystery, but somehow I knew that I had to keep getting back up. Persistence might be a virtue, but I was persistently wrong.

(In a way, it followed masochism: exciting at first, then tiresome, and finally, humiliating. But unlike a true masochist, this humiliation was not pursued for its own sake, and I eventually rediscovered something called My Dignity.) 

This Truth, if that’s what it was, did not need be so painful. (That was my fault.) Apparently, it could even be freeing. (And it was--after the fullness of it’s realization quintupled my pain and suffering. (And that was just the beginning.))

But looooong before The Quintupling, in the early days of discovering that my brain could be used for more than finding the easy way out of work I disliked, I discovered fragments of the Truth in the form of ideas: the precursor to actions.

Ideas were these things that people said, that then caused them to act. Sometimes, if people said the right things over and over enough, they could actively turn abstract ideas into physical objects, like airplanes or swords or buildings or pizza. Sometimes abstract ideas 'became' non-physical, like laws, or elections, or governments or TV shows. Sometimes they didn't become anything. They remained equations on a chalkboard, or scribbles in a notebook. These ideas weren't bad, they just weren't complete yet. (However, some bad ideas were complete.)

For the first time in my life I became interested in the world outside of limited experiences with the people I knew personally. I listened to and read all different kinds of ideas without any concept of context or consistency. From these thought perusals I’d recalled some past topics I'd heard referenced in the college classes I'd attended with my eyes closed, and a light bulb went off in my head. 'Ohhhhhhh!! So that's what they meant by abortion/illegal immigration/global warming/atheism/feminism/the Iraq War/social justice/socialism/gay marriage!' (Yet somehow, I'd still earned a degree from a liberal arts college.) But making connections and forming opinions from this flurry of ideas was confusing and overwhelming. It became easier to simply repeat what I'd learned on Talk Radio (other people’s ideas), which was fine because I realized that I didn't know enough of anything to form opinions of my own. Yet.

After spending time among all these varying ideas with no guide I discovered the first truth: that all ideas were not created equal. Pizza was great, but socialism was not. Buildings sometimes collapsed when planes rammed into them, and some people thought that governments were responsible based on complicated—and conflicting---material evidence. Some people thought such attacks were deserved, and others thought no acts of violence were ever deserved by innocent people. 

With so many facts to sift through, I had to take an expert's word, as I was not an expert myself. But experts in all disciplines contradicted one another, and I wondered: how can truth be discerned through disagreement?

Ideologies were the easy way out of this conundrum. An ideology was a compilation of ideas that formed a framework for truth, but not the Truth itself. In other words, an ideology was an easily applicable label for any layman—myself included—that needed a cause to give their meandering life purpose. Laymen—myself included--were happy to be on ‘the right side of history’ by labeling themselves an ‘-ist.’ In those early days I very much enjoyed going to verbal war with opposing ideologues like my Dad, using the facts I was spoon-fed from other, more cleverly disguised ideologues from Talk Radio. A “conversation” between two ideologues was a back and forth of talking points, and I’d smirk, knowing how to verbally parry my opponent, charitably letting them finish what I already knew they were going to say. They would threaten to punch me in the face for being the type of ‘-ist’ they were trained to hate, and I'd smirk again, begging for it. 

Ideological adherents don’t recognize their own thoughts because they take facts at face value from entertainment professionals. They are trained with what to say when they hear a “fake fact' from the opposition, as well as how to determine if a fellow layperson is The Opposition, deserving of rebuke: they disagree. 

A talking point was not a thinking point. I was persuaded by a seductive speaker and conditioned with guileful phrases to trip up my ideological opponent when we inevitably crossed paths. (Mainstream media is an ideologue factory!) Packaged with some facts was the arrogance that my opponent was wrong, and I was right. By design this adrenaline fueled these heated “conversations.” Without any understanding of the Truth, I unknowingly became a repository and mouthpiece for someone else’s ideas, a means for someone else’s ends. Talk Radio was only slightly different than state school. And here I’d thought that I was thinking!

More time spent among the warring ideologies proved that each contained truth fragments, but fell short of reaching the Truth, usually because ideologies disproved one another, in an endless loop of disputation. The essence of every ideology takes a fragment of Truth--namely through the virtue of Justice--to build a framework. Many good people fall for ideologies, committing and believing evils in the name of Justice/their ideology of choice. Often this is because ideological factoids have replaced Truth. 

Facts were not the Truth. I could learn facts and the Truth would still knock me down. Facts merely reached for the Truth--some having more truth in them than others--but they were too often conflicting and confusing (and politicized) to be anything more than fodder for ideological fodder. The Truth humbles all who approach it. The Truth sets us free from a dead guy's ideologies from the 19th century because the Truth never changes. The Truth isn’t on any quest to be right, as the Truth just is right. The Truth doesn’t need to humiliate opponents with some cherry-picked facts. The Truth Is.

Ideas alone couldn't guide me towards Truth. Gatekeepers—for mysterious, but predictable reasons--built an ideological wall that kept those searching for meaning from reaching the Truth. 

So how do we free ourselves from this ideological narrative? How do we escape ideology? How can we have our own ideas, rooted in Truth, Beauty and Goodness?

Pray

No comments:

Post a Comment